free 2-day shipping on orders $75+

Best Sellers

They don't call 'em best sellers for nothing! Shop our best selling cookie menu and get a taste of what put us on the map!
  1. Build Your Own Box | 1 dozen - Chocolate and the Chip
    Build Your Own Assortment Box
    $6.00
    View options
  2. The Best Seller Box
    The Best Seller Box
    from $23.99
    View options
  3. The Sweet Escape Box
    The Sweet Escape Box
    from $18.00
    View options
  4. The Fancy Box: Lavender and Original Chocolate Chip - Chocolate and the Chip
    The Fancy Box: Lavender and Original Chocolate Chip
    from $23.99
    View options
  5. The Best Dang Chocolate Chip Cookies
    The Best Dang Chocolate Chip Cookies
    from $18.00
    View options
  6. Cue the Confetti Birthday Cookies
    Cue the Confetti Birthday Cookies
    from $18.00
    View options
  7. Peanut'ella Swirl Cookies
    Peanut'ella Swirl Cookies
    from $18.00
    View options
  8. The BIG Original Cookie Cake with Nutella - Chocolate and the Chip
    The BIG Nutella Chocolate Chip Cookie Cake
    from $39.99
    View options
  9. Malted Oreo Bestie Treats
    Sold out
    Malted Oreo Bestie Treats
    from $8.00

    Sold out

  10. The Classic Two-tiered Cookie Cake | Locals Only
    The Classic Two-tiered Cookie Cake | Locals Only
    from $59.99
    View options
  11. Chocolate Rice Krispie Treats
    Chocolate Rice Krispie Treats
    from $15.00
    View options